Wednesday, April 01, 2009

Pennsylvania Homeowner Uses "Produce The Note" Self-Help Strategy In Attempt To Fend Off Foreclosure

In Ellwood City, Pennsylvania, KDKA-TV Channel 2 reports:
  • A Lawrence County man is trying a new strategy to save his home. Mark Strohecker, of Ellwood City, is a former firefighter who is on disability. When his adjustable rate mortgage jumped, he was unable to make payments. Facing foreclosure, he used a strategy promoted by a Florida-based website called the Consumer Warning Network. He filed a motion asking the lender to "produce the note." "Provide to me the promissory note to show to me that they are indeed the rightful owner of my property here," Strohecker said.(1)

***

  • Strohecker tells KDKA his lender has told him they can't find the note. It's unclear what will happen next. He plans on filing more paperwork in court next week.

For the story, see Ellwood City Man Uses 'Note' Strategy To Save Home.

For the KDKA-TV Channel 2 video, see 'Note' Strategy Could Stop Home Foreclosure.

See also The Consumer Warning Network: Homeowner Stops Foreclosure after filing “Produce the Note”

  • [T]he fight for Strohecker’s home is not over yet. The Judge’s order delays the foreclosure sale until May 13th. The order gives the plaintiff, LaSalle Bank National Association, time to come up with the original note, or, if it was lost or destroyed, to prove that LaSalle is the rightful owner of the note. The Judge’s order cites a potential loan modification as a reason for stopping the Sheriff’s Sale. “Said sale is stayed until the next sale scheduled for May 13, 2009, as there is the strong possibility of federal relief for mortgage foreclosures,” Judge Cox wrote in his order.

Go here for more on Produce The Note “How-To”.

Go here for Sample Foreclosure Legal Documents.

For posts that reference the failure of mortgage lenders and their attorneys to file the proper paperwork when bringing foreclosure actions, Go Here, Go Here, Go Here, Go Here, Go Here, and Go Here.

(1) For those in Mr. Strohecker's position, it might be a good idea to request that the mortgage company prove, not only that it has the note, but that it also has the legal right to enforce the note through foreclosure by demanding that it produce, among other things:

  • a complete "chain of title" tracing assignment of the mortgage from the loan originator or other party named in the mortgage;
  • all necessary affidavits, powers of attorney, etc. that impact on the validity of the written assignments of mortgage;
  • the pooling and servicing agreement if a loan servicer is involved (see Max Gardner’s Top Resasons for Wanting a Pooling Servicing Agreement). ThetaMissingDocsMtg

Foreclosure Sale Called Off As KC Homeowner Files Suit Alleging Fraud In Lending Process

In Kansas City, Missouri, The Kansas City Star reports:
  • Sherrita Richardson’s home was to be taken in foreclosure on Monday, making her just one more American caught in the nation’s widening foreclosure crisis. Instead, Richardson became a rare statistic. She’s won a reprieve. The lender has stopped the foreclosure to investigate Richardson’s claims that she was the victim of an inflated appraisal and fraud.

***

  • Richardson has been assisted by retired attorney Sid Willens, who lobbied the lender to stop the foreclosure until her claims could be investigated. [...] What’s more, Willens has filed a lawsuit against the mortgage broker and seller. She said they misled Richardson and committed a fraud in the deal, using an inflated appraisal and misrepresenting how much money she would put into the deal.

For more, see Foreclosure halted while lender investigates claims that woman was victim of inflated appraisal and fraud.

See also, KMBC-TV Channel 12: Woman Successful In Fight To Stop Foreclosure (Attorney Tries To Get KC Home Reappraised).

Sloppy Underwriting, Probable Fraud Driving Surging FHA Default Rates In Florida?

The Wall Street Journal's Developments Blog reports:
  • While FHA serious delinquencies have soared since last summer, nowhere is that more true than in Florida, at least according to the Monthly Report to the FHA Commissioner for January (released last week). Of the 50 metro areas with the highest default rates in the FHA’s Single-Family Mortgage Program in December 2008 (the latest data shown in the report), 14 were from Florida – with five Florida metros making the top-ten list.

***

  • While plunging home prices and a sharply deteriorating economy were behind much of the horrible performance of FHA loans in Florida, there appears to be something else going on: sloppy underwriting, and probable fraud. Reports of sharply increasing early payment defaults (where borrowers either make no or just one payment before defaulting) are apparently heavily concentrated in Florida [...].

For more, see Florida: The Not-So-Sunshine State for FHA.

In a related story, see The Washington Post: The Next Hit: Quick Defaults (More FHA-Backed Mortgages Go Bad Without a Single Payment).

Florida AG: Mortgage Fraud Crisis Like A "State Of Emergency"

The Tampa Tribune reports:
  • As more Floridians face losing their homes to foreclosure, more crooks emerge to take advantage of them, and the state's attorney general says the problem has become a crisis. [...] "This mortgage fraud crisis is similar to a state of emergency. It will take an all-hands-on-deck approach between our state's agencies to effectively address our citizens' concerns," McCollum said. Mortgage fraud topped the list of complaints logged by his office in 2008, and the state has pursued civil and criminal action against dozens of companies and individuals accused of mortgage fraud. [... Mortgage] Rescue fraud continues to be the top mortgage fraud complaint by homeowners. Many say companies are taking their money and not helping them modify their mortgages.

Source: Florida Mortgage Fraud Crisis Called 'State Of Emergency'

See also, Florida Attorney General press release: Attorney General Calls for Cooperative Approach to State's Mortgage Fraud Issues (Situation likened to a “state of emergency”).

Go here for a sample of AG McCollum's letter to Florida regulators.

Ohio AG Indicts Two in $38M+ Mortgage Fraud Involving Seven Apartment Complexes

From the Office of the Ohio Attorney General:
  • Ohio Attorney General Richard Cordray's Ohio Organized Crime Investigations Commission announced today the indictments and arrests of two men alleged to have perpetrated one of the largest mortgage fraud schemes ever in Franklin County. John Wanek, 55, of Phoenix, Ariz., and Robert Swanigan, 30, of Mesa, Ariz., were indicted Friday by the Franklin County Grand Jury and were arrested Monday in Arizona.

***

  • The indictment charges Wanek with 33 counts, including engaging in a pattern of corrupt activity, theft, forgery, telecommunications fraud, money laundering, and receiving stolen property. Swanigan is charged with theft and falsification. [...] Investigators report that in the past six years Wanek obtained commercial loans in the Columbus area through the use of false statements and forged documents. Wanek obtained loans for the purchase of six Columbus apartment complexes and one Indianapolis apartment complex. Wanek then defaulted on the loans.

For the entire Ohio AG press release, see Investigation of Multi-Million Dollar Apartment Complex Mortgage Fraud Leads to Indictments and Arrests.

For the indictment, see State of Ohio v. Wanek.

Tuesday, March 31, 2009

California AG Declares War On Loan Modification Scams; Will Target Bogus TV, Other Mass Media Ads Offering Useless Deals

In Los Angeles, California, the Los Angeles Times reports:
  • State Atty. Gen. Jerry Brown pledged Saturday to investigate and prosecute businesses that charge struggling homeowners fees to help get more favorable terms for repayment of their mortgage loans. "We have lawyers, we have investigators, and we will go after those who break the law by falsely representing what they can do," Brown said at a congressional hearing in South Los Angeles.

  • Brown, a Democrat planning to run for governor next year, vowed to focus specifically on bogus television ads that lure homeowners into expensive mortgage consulting deals that are useless. "We will document the rip-offs that are over the mass media as best we can," he said.(1)

For more, see California attorney general promises to tackle homeowner scams (At a congressional hearing in South Los Angeles, Jerry Brown says his office will investigate and prosecute firms that charge fees for bogus mortgage consultant deals).

(1) Unlike his counterparts in some states who are prosecuting loan modification foreclosure rescue fraud with civil lawsuits, Attorney General Brown has recently been bringing criminal actions against the alleged perpetrators charging grand theft and criminal violations of the state's foreclosure consultant statute. See:

Lenders Abandoning Foreclosure Actions In Some Markets; Dilapidated Collateral Not Worth Repossessing; Homeowners Left On The Hook For Code Violations

In South Bend, Indiana, The New York Times reports:
  • [C]ity officials and housing advocates here and in cities as varied as Buffalo,(1) Kansas City, Mo., and Jacksonville, Fla., say they are seeing an unsettling development: Banks are quietly declining to take possession of properties at the end of the foreclosure process, most often because the cost of the ordeal — from legal fees to maintenance — exceeds the diminishing value of the real estate.(2)

  • The so-called bank walkaways rarely mean relief for the property owners, caught unaware months after the fact, and often mean additional financial burdens and bureaucratic headaches. Technically, they still owe on the mortgage, but as a practicality, rarely would a mortgage holder receive any more payments on the loan.(3) The way mortgages are bundled and resold, it can be enormously time-consuming just trying to determine what company holds the loan on a property thought to be in foreclosure.(4)

For more, see Banks Starting to Walk Away on Foreclosures.

Go here for other posts on code violation & other problems associated with homes in legal limbo.

Thanks to Bill Collins of Crossroads Abstract, Rochester, NY for the heads-up on this story.

(1) According to the story, in Buffalo, where officials said the problem had reached “epidemic” proportions in recent months, the city sued 37 banks last year (see City of Buffalo v. ABN Amro Mortgage Group Inc., et al.), claiming they were responsible for the deterioration of at least 57 abandoned homes; the city chose a sampling of houses to include in the lawsuit, even though the banks had walked away from many more foreclosures. So far, five banks have settled.

(2) Reportedly, Chuck Leone, the South Bend city attorney, made this observation on the foreclosing lender walk-aways: “We see it one of two ways. One is that the bank will simply dismiss the foreclosure complaint. The other is that the mortgage holder will follow through and take a judgment of foreclosure, but then not schedule the property for sheriff’s sale.”

(3) The article highlights the story of one local property owner who though she lost a two-family rental home to foreclosure, which fell victim to looters after her tenants moved out. The City of South Bend contacted her recently, demanding that she resume maintenance on the property. The sheriff’s sale had been canceled at the last minute, leaving the property title — and a world of trouble — in her name. Reportedly, the home is now so worthless the city plans to demolish it — another bill for which she will be liable.

(4) One recent story (see National Public Radio: Banks Refusing To Take Back Foreclosed Properties) reported that Cleveland, Ohio Housing Court officials said they are now seeing homeowners take matters into their own hands when dealing with the abandonment of foreclosure lawsuits by lenders. One instance is cited involving a foreclosing lender that was reluctant to complete the foreclosure process and repossess a dilapidated property. In that case, the homeowner simply deeded back the property to the lender by preparing a deed, naming the lender as grantee, and recording it.

Such a conveyance may ultimately be found to be ineffective because the mortgage lender surely would assert that it never "accepted" the deed conveyed by the owner of the dilapidated wreck collateralizing its loan (ie. to be effective, a deed must be both "delivered" by the grantor-owner, and "accepted" by the grantee-lender; in other words, no acceptance = no conveyance). However, recording a deed in the name of the unwitting lender may, under state law, create a legal presumption that it has been "accepted" by the lender (see Janian v. Barnes, 284 A.D.2d 717, 718; 727 N.Y.S.2d 182 (N.Y. App. Div. 3d Dep't 2001)) until such time that it straightens out the mess by going into court, presenting evidence to a judge that there was no actual acceptance, and obtaining a judgment declaring the deed to be void. Unless and until it does so, it could arguably be treated as the legal owner of (and find itself legally responsible for the code violations on) its abandoned dilapidated loan collateral. Inasmuch as many mortgage holders, their loan servicers, and their assembly line foreclosure mill attorneys have proven themselves to be quite clumsy when handling the paperwork relating to their mortgages, it could be quite some time before they discover that title to the loan collateral has been put in their name - probably when they start getting tagged with the code violations - and possibly even longer before they figure out what to do. responsibility code violations foreclosure

Illinois Woman Charged With Felony Theft In Alleged Loan Modification Scam

In Sherman, Illinois, the The State Journal Register reports:
  • A Sherman woman has been arrested in connection with an alleged real estate fraud scheme, including trying to sell property she did not own and conducting a mortgage rescue scam, authorities said. Tamptha S. Hickman, 39, turned herself in to police after a warrant for her arrest on a charge of felony theft was issued Tuesday. She was released from jail after posting $1,000 bail.

***

  • Under her company name, police said, Hickman mailed out as many as 500 letters to homeowners who were in the foreclosure process and claimed she could help save their homes at no cost to them. One homeowner who got the letter contacted Hickman, who allegedly told the homeowner that she had contacted the victim’s mortgage company and that if she wrote Hickman a check right away for $3,800, the home would not be foreclosed upon. Hickman then would negotiate a payment plan for the rest of the debt, she allegedly told the woman. The victim gave the check to Hickman and a week later contacted the mortgage company to make sure the payment had been made. It hadn’t been, police said. Authorities believe Hickman pocketed the money.

  • The victim never went to authorities about Hickman’s alleged scam, but police found her after going through Hickman’s financial records. “The victim never came forward because she was embarrassed and didn’t know there was anything she could do about it,” Hill said.

For more, see Sherman woman arrested in alleged real estate fraud scheme.

Real Estate Agent Charged In Staten Island Gas Station Heist; Used Phony Deed To Transfer Title To Client's Business Property To Son, Say Cops

The following excerpt appeared in a recent NYPD Daily Blotter column in the New York Post:
  • A real-estate agent was busted after he tried to steal a million-dollar Tompkinsville property from the owner, sources said. Mike Odeh, 53, was hired by the owner to sell a gas station on Bay Street and Hannah Street, the sources said.

  • The owner changed his mind about the sale and notified Odeh, but the agent allegedly forged a phony deed and on Feb. 17 filed it with the County Clerk's Office, police said. The phony deed transferred the property to Odeh's son, who tried to sell the property for $300,000, cops said. The property is worth about $1.5 million, according to court papers.

  • The owner learned of the scheme from another agent, and cops arrested Odeh at his Grasmere home Thursday. He was charged with grand larceny and criminal possession of a forged instrument.

Source: NYPD Daily Blotter (excerpt appears halfway down page).

Go here, Go here, Go here, Go here, Go here, and Go here for other posts related to deed or refinancing scams by forgery, swindle, power of attorney abuse, etc. DeedGammaTheft

Report: Supply Of Publicly Funded Legal Aid, Pro Bono Services "Entirely Inadequate" To Meet State's Needs

Buried at the end of a New York Law Journal article on a new volunteer attorney initiative to assist unrepresented defendants in civil cases [credit for the idea for this program attributed to former New York Court of Appeals' Chief Judge Judith S. Kaye](1) is this excerpt on the state of publicly funded legal aid and pro bono services in New York:
  • In a report earlier this month, the Office of the Deputy Chief Administrative Judge for Justice Initiatives termed the supply of publicly funded legal aid and pro bono services "entirely inadequate" to meet the need. In 2007, Kaye estimated that about 1.8 million litigants appeared without a lawyer in New York state courts.

Source: Economy Prompts N.Y. Courts' New Program for Volunteer Attorneys.

For the March, 2009 report, see Expanding Access To Justice In New York State (A Ten-Year Report Prepared By The Office Of The Deputy Chief Administrative Judge For Justice Initiatives).

(1) In an interview Wednesday, Kaye said she had been thinking of ways to bring the "regrettably increasing supply side of lawyer time" caused by the failing economy to the "aid of the regrettably increasing demand side" of people needing legal services. "I am so heartbroken every day to read the lead news item in the [New York] Law Journal about more lawyers being suspended, exited, encouraged to do something other than their law firm work," Kaye said. "And there are the courts just flooded with foreclosure cases, flooded with credit card debt cases, flooded with Family Court filings."

IRS Publication 4681: Canceled Debts, Foreclosures, Reposessions & Abandonments

Those who are trying to figure out how to handle the tax ramifications of a cancellation of debt on a short sale, foreclosure sale, loan modification, or any other debt cancellation might want to consult IRS Publication 4681: Canceled Debts, Foreclosures, Reposessions and Abandonments.

For more from the IRS on cancellation of debt, see:

Monday, March 30, 2009

Miami Feds Bag 10 Suspects In Alleged Cash Back Mortgage Fraud Scam; Another Remains At Large

In Miami, Florida, the South Florida Business Journal report:
  • Eleven South Floridians have been indicted in a mortgage fraud scheme totaling more than $4.7 million, according to the U.S. attorney for the Southern District of Florida. Ten of the defendants were arrested last week;(1) the 11th, identified as Julissa Amaral of Miami, remains at large. The defendants are alleged to have set up 13 fraudulent sales of homes involving six different South Florida properties between August 2004 and September 2008.

***

  • It is alleged that, at the closing of the sales, the 11 would then resell the property to other straw buyers, each time significantly increasing the price of the properties. [The two alleged ringleaders] then would divert the proceeds from the sales for their personal use, according to the indictment. The straw buyers never lived in the property, nor paid any of the closing costs or mortgage payments. Once the loans closed, five of the six properties went into foreclosure. It is estimated the losses on the six properties were $1.6 million.

Source: Eleven indicted in mortgage fraud scheme.

See also, the U.S. Attorney (Miami, FL) press release: Eleven From Miami-Dade Charged In Mortgage Fraud Scheme.

(1) Juan A. Garcia and Yenisley Acosta, both of Miami, were the alleged ringleaders, according to the indictment. The other defendants, alleged to have posed as straw buyers, applying for loans using false information in their applications, according to the indictment, are identified as Juan J. Garcia, of Hialeah; Omar Alfonso, of Hialeah Gardens; Yurima Espinosa, of Miami; Yolanda Gomez, of Hialeah Gardens; Ulises Avila, of Miami; Luis Cordero, of Miami; Roberto Portilla, of Miami; Julissa Amaral, of Miami; and Eugenio Garcia, of Miami.

Buying Residential Mortgage Loans? Documentation Issues & Risks Increase As "Produce The Note" Strategy Gains In Popularity

An article on mondaq.com advises that:
  • Investors considering the purchase of residential mortgage loans should include on their diligence checklists verifying the mortgage loan documentation to ensure they will be in a position to enforce the Note and realize on the mortgage if necessary. This entails making sure there is a proper negotiation of all Notes in accordance with UCC requirements, obtaining physical custody of the original Notes, and obtaining written assignments of mortgages in recordable form.

The article highlights the following issues that investors can expect to be raised if they fail in their due diligence:

  • [O]ne issue that has become an increasing focus of litigation between residential mortgage lenders and borrowers is the adequacy of the "paper trail" of mortgage loan securitizations. [...] Consumer lawyers around the country have sought to capitalize on the inability of some mortgage servicers and foreclosure counsel to adequately "prove up" the mortgage loan documentation to prevent or delay foreclosure of defaulted loans.

***

  • The principal points of contention have been, first, whether possession of the borrower's original promissory note is a prerequisite to exercise of foreclosure remedies; and, second, whether the foreclosing creditor must show a complete "chain of title" tracing assignment of the mortgage from the loan originator or other party named in the mortgage.

***

  • Increasingly, at the urging of debtors and debtor's counsel, state courts and in particular bankruptcy courts presented with motions for relief from the automatic stay to foreclose defaulted residential mortgage loans are requiring creditors to produce original Notes.

***

  • A related issue concerns who is entitled to enforce the Note. It has been held that "[i]f a loan has been securitized, the real party in interest is the trustee of the securitization trust, not the servicing agent." In re Hwang, 396 B.R. 757, 767 (Bankr. C.D. Cal. 2008). Enforcement and foreclosure proceedings are often brought by the loan servicer, sometimes in its own name and sometimes in the name of its principal pursuant to a power of attorney. Any claimant who is not the "holder" of the Note within the meaning of the Uniform Commercial Code and in actual physical possession of the Note may find its standing challenged by borrowers and courts.

***

  • The other principal line of attack by borrowers and their counsel concerns the validity of written assignments of mortgages.

***

  • Another complication concerns the role of MERS-- the Mortgage Electronic Registration System, Inc. MERS was established to maintain an electronic off-record mortgage registry, thus eliminating the need for filings in the public land records whenever a mortgage changes hands.

For the article, see Documentation Issues And Risks In Purchasing Residential Mortgage Loans (article starts half way down the webpage).

For posts that reference the failure of mortgage lenders and their attorneys to file the proper paperwork when bringing foreclosure actions, Go Here, Go Here, Go Here, Go Here, Go Here, and Go Here. ThetaMissingDocsMtg

Court Orders Temporary Shut Down Of Miami Loan Modification Firm; Company Directed To Refund Upfront Fees Within 90 Days

From the Office of the Florida Attorney General:
  • Attorney General Bill McCollum [Friday] obtained a temporary injunction against Lincoln Lending Services, LLC and owner Rita Gomez, prohibiting the company from engaging in any type of consumer-debt related service or mortgage modification service and from taking payment from consumers for such services until further order of the court. The company will also be required to preserve and allow inspection of its records and refrain from liquidating its assets.

  • In addition to freezing the company’s assets, the order requires that the company refund any up-front payments made by consumers for foreclosure-related rescue services subsequent to October 1, 2008, the effective date of the law prohibiting up-front charges.

  • These refunds should be completed within 90 days and will be made without the necessity of consumers filing a claim. The Attorney General's Economic Crimes Division sued Lincoln Lending and Gomez [last] week (press release, lawsuit) for allegedly charging up-front fees for loan modification services in violation of the Foreclosure Rescue Fraud Prevention Act. The Attorney General’s office has received hundreds of complaints regarding this case since the lawsuit was filed. Both parties agreed to this order.

For the Florida AG's press release, see Temporary Injunction Obtained in Foreclosure Rescue Fraud Lawsuit.

Ex-Subprime Mortgage Peddlers Now Running Loan Modification Scams

Bloomberg News ran a lengthy story describing how loan modification scam artists have popped up all over the country. Many of the players are described as out-of-work real estate professionals who peddled subprime mortgages during the boom who are now pocketing hundreds of thousands of dollars in advance fees and disappear or bleed their victims by charging monthly payments. The following excerpt describes one mortgage broker who jumped on the loan modification bandwagon and who now finds herself in hot water:
  • In early 2008, Cheryl Ann Montero, a California mortgage broker, held a series of free seminars [for homeowners facing foreclosure] in the clubhouse of the Lone Tree Golf Course in Contra Costa County, a suburban area near San Francisco. [...] She said her firm, Freedom Financial Solutions, could pressure lenders to stop foreclosures by challenging the legality of loan agreements, according to court records. Her fee: $2,500 upfront and a $2,000 monthly payment to cover legal costs. Promoting her services on the Web site Craigslist, Montero, a blond-haired, blue-eyed woman who looked like a soccer mom, became known as a foreclosure escape artist.

***

  • She was also ripping people off, says Ken McCormick, a prosecutor in the Contra Costa County District Attorney’s office. A player in a new confidence game exploiting soaring defaults, Montero didn’t have a team of attorneys to confront lenders. Instead, her firm took a small ownership stake in some of her clients’ houses and filed for bankruptcy, temporarily suspending foreclosure proceedings on those homes, according to an investigative report filed in court by prosecutors.

***

  • She couldn’t make it in real estate anymore, so she just changed hats,” McCormick says. “But she was taking money and doing nothing.” The prosecutor charged Montero with 36 counts of grand theft and related charges in December. She pleaded not guilty and is free on $100,000 bail.(1)

For the entire story, see Subprime Swindlers Reconnect to Homeowners in Foreclosure Scams.

(1) According to the story, Montero ran a three-person operation in which she told homeowners that she could find technical violations committed by lenders in loan contracts, an investigative report filed in court says. Montero blundered during one of her seminars by dropping the name of an attorney who she claimed was working with her, the report says. One of Montero’s clients called the lawyer, who had never heard of Montero, and he in turn complained to the authorities. “That’s what gave us a heads up,” says McCormick, the prosecutor.

Assignee Liability Essential In Enforcement Of Lending, Consumer Protection Laws

A recent op-ed column in the Atlanta Journal Constitution by William J. Brennan Jr. of the Atlanta Legal Aid Society, the founder and director of Atlanta Legal Aid’s Home Defense Program, makes an observation on a weakness in Georgia state law in connection with the enforcement of lending and consumer protection laws:
  • Many consumer advocates support the lending law revisions in Senate Bill 57, but the changes are window dressing for those of us who represent poor people faced with foreclosure. The law falls short in one crucial area — assignee liability.

  • Assignee liability entitles a bilked borrower facing foreclosure to sue not only the originator of the loan but also the current holder. It’s important because most loans are sold and transferred into mortgage-backed security pools. SB 57 doesn’t mandate assignee liability, which means that homeowners would be left with no clear recourse.

For more, see Once mortgages sold, homeowners often left stranded. UndoMortgageLoans TILAdelta

Sunday, March 29, 2009

Tulsa Bar Response To Call To Ante Up Financial Help For Legal Aid Underwhelming As Governor, Others Attempt To Bridge "Justice Gap" In Oklahoma

In Tulsa, Oklahoma, an op-ed column in Tulsa World reports:
  • Two hundred Tulsa law firms that had not contributed to Legal Aid Services of Oklahoma in past fund drives recently received an appeal to help match a $35,000 challenge grant from the George Kaiser Family Foundation. So far, response is underwhelming; four firms dug deep and gave a total of $1,000. The annual public fund drive continues, led by Gov. Brad Henry and first lady Kim Henry.

***

  • [I]f this were a typical year — LASO again would serve 20,000 clients, who could not otherwise afford a lawyer to aid them with civil legal matters. And LASO again, lamentably, would turn away another 20,000 Oklahomans because it did not have enough staff to get them past the front door. Even in good times demand far outstrips resources. "We call it the 'justice gap,' " says LASO's Gayla Machell. "They're all the people who cannot afford an attorney's help but cannot make it to the front of the line at Legal Aid."

  • This, however, will not be an ordinary year. Here and nationally Legal Aid groups are witnessing crushing demand. LASO staff across the state can only hope that the number they must turn away remains at 20,000 because the figure could go far higher.

For more, see Justice for all? Not really (Lack of Legal Aid funding creates unbalanced system).

Utah AG Charges Couple With Multiple Felonies In Alleged Equity Stripping Foreclosure Rescue Scam; Seeks Asset Freeze, Criminal Forfeiture, $500K Bail

From the Office of the Utah Attorney General:
  • The Utah Attorney General's Office [Friday] charged the CEO of Utah Financial Inc., Midvale, Utah, and his wife with 18 second-degree felony counts for allegedly running a lucrative mortgage fraud scheme. Utah Financial President Brendan Tyler Cassity, 36, and Olivia Cassity, 29, were both charged with 15 counts of communications fraud, one count of racketeering and two counts of money laundering.

***

  • According to court documents, the Cassitys allegedly prepared their own appraisals using the name of a separate licensed appraiser and substituting photos of more lavish homes as part of those appraisals to inflate the value of the real estate described in those appraisals. They then allegedly used straw buyers to obtain loans far in excess of the true value of the properties. Equity was then allegedly skimmed from the properties in order to gain tax advantages and buy other properties. The alleged scheme may have netted several million dollars. The Attorney General's Office has asked a judge to freeze the assets of the defendants and is seeking criminal forfeiture of their business at 193 East Fort Union Boulevard in Midvale and their home in Salt Lake City. Prosecutors are also asking that bail be set at $500,000 for each defendant.(1)

For the Utah AG's press release, see Midvale Mortgage Company Owners Charged With Fraud.

For earlier post on this case, see Utah AG Raids Foreclosure Rescue Operator's Office, Home; Investigators Mum About What They're Looking For.

(1) "The ripple effect of mortgage fraud schemes across the country is far-reaching and significant," says Attorney General Mark L. Shurtleff. "The Utah Attorney General's Office places a high priority on uncovering and squelching predatory practices of unscrupulous mortgage brokers. Some of these so-called ‘mortgage assistance' programs are merely schemes to defraud people of their money and their homes."

NY Courts Roll Out Attorney-Assisted Self Help Initiative For State Residents Fighting Foreclosure, Personal Debt, Landlord-Tenant, Other Lawsuits

The New York Law Journal reports:
  • Administrators of New York courts rolled out a new program Thursday to enlist attorneys, many of whom may be laid off or on reduced work schedules due to the sour economy, to provide legal advice and expertise to pro se litigants. The initiative will differ from traditional pro bono work in that lawyers will not represent poor clients in court nor provide assistance throughout their cases.

  • Rather, lawyers in the new Volunteer Attorney Program will make themselves available to multiple pro se litigants to help them prepare petitions and other court paperwork, advise them about what might happen in court and interpret orders from courts, Chief Administrative Judge Ann Pfau said.(1) The program at first will focus on providing legal services in courts in New York City and in Westchester, Suffolk and Nassau counties.

***

  • Free training will be available, and attorneys will earn CLE credit for volunteering under the program, according to court administrators. [...] Lawyers in the program will be shielded from liability for the advice they dispense under §17 of the Public Officers Law, according to Lawrence Marks, director of administration for the Unified Court System.

For more, see Economy Prompts N.Y. Courts' New Program for Volunteer Attorneys.

(1) According to the story, Pfau said the need for attorneys to help pro se litigants is particularly acute in cases that reflect the bad economy, such as foreclosures, tenant-landlord disputes, personal debt, child support and other matters in Family Court and small estate settlements in Surrogate's Court. Both employed and unemployed lawyers can participate, Pfau said. Applications and other information about the program are available on the Unified Court System's Web site:

http://www.courts.state.ny.us/attorneys/volunteer.shtml

Court officials will give examples of the types of matters where attorneys can provide legal advice and volunteering lawyers can express preferences for counties where they want to serve. There is no minimum time commitment.

Jointly Owned Marital Real Estate Facing Foreclosure - Did Both Spouses Sign The Paperwork?

In a recent column appearing in The Herald News (Fall River, Massachusetts), foreclosure defense and bankruptcy attorney Glenn Russell Jr. writes about one problem facing lenders in some foreclosure actions that has gone pretty much unnoticed in general media reports - What happens if a sloppy loan originator and/or title closer obtained only one spouse's signature on a promissory note and mortgage in connection with property owned by husband and wife jointly as tenants by the entirety?
  • If your lender is seeking to foreclose on your home, and you live in a state like Massachusetts that recognizes a type of property ownership known as “Tenancy by the Entirety,” you have some protection.(1) Both spouses’ signatures are required to be on all of the loan and property documentation when you purchased your home.

***

  • During the mortgage frenzy over the past 7 years, mortgage brokers could not keep up with the paperwork and became very sloppy, or worse. Many times, these people were in too much of a rush, and lacked the necessary knowledge about this issue, to even ask for both signatures.

For the entire column, see Tell bank where to stick its foreclosure note.

(1) According to Russell, tenancy by the entirety is recognized in 28 states, including Massachusetts. In most cases the foreclosing lender will not be able to foreclose and sell your property, but will be able to place a lien on the property equal to the spouse’s share who did sign the loan documents, as long as the couple remains married and alive. He goes on to point out, however, that this share is only a “contingent” interest, meaning that the lender would only take actual ownership of the property if the non-signing spouse pre-deceased the signing spouse. If the married couple divorce, the lender can proceed with the foreclosure process.

I would add to this point by observing that in the State of Florida, a mortgage on a primary residence (ie. homestead property) signed only by one spouse (irrespective of how title is held) is treated as null and void pursuant to the provisions of Article X Section 4 of the Florida Constitution (relating to the state homestead exemption from forced sale) and the state court interpretations thereof. In that case, the foreclosing lender will find itself having no recourse at all against the property and, accordingly, will be left holding the bag.

While I have yet to see specific recent cases recounted in general media reports on incidents where only one spouse signed the note and mortgage on property owned as tenants by the entirety that is facing foreclosure, anectdotes thereon are definitely out there. ThetaMissingDocsMtg

Lawyer To Challenge Raid In Alleged $50M NY Dominatrix-Connected Mortgage Fraud Scam

The New York Law Journal reports:
  • Now that a lawyer has been arrested in connection with a bizarre real estate fraud that allegedly recruited straw buyers at a dominatrix club, he has standing to challenge the warrant that authorized a raid on his law office last month, his attorney said Thursday. It is "dangerous precedent to allow a prosecutor to do this in an adversarial system to a lawyer," said Kathy B. Huang, the Manhattan attorney representing George O. Guldi, 55, a former Democratic legislator and Westhampton Beach, N.Y., solo practitioner.

For more, see Attorney to Challenge Office Raid After Arrest in Mortgage Scam Tied to Dominatrix Club.

For earlier reports on this story, see:

Customer Complaints On Loan Modification Firms From Around The Country

The following assorted links are to stories of financially strapped homewowners complaining about being screwed out of upfront fees paid to loan modification companies for allegedly worthless promises.
  • Las Vegas, Nevada: Woman evicted after home is foreclosed on. One woman is putting a face on the foreclosure crisis. Evicted from her home Wednesday afternoon with nowhere to go and making matters worse, she says she tried everything to get the bank to work with her. That includes hiring a man who is now facing felony theft charges. But still, the constable showed up at her door. She and her husband are former clients of Jack Ferm, the owner of the infamous U.S. Justice Foundation. Carrie paid him $1,900 because she says he promised to help renegotiate their loan. Instead, Ferm was recently arrested and charged with felony theft.

  • Pleasant View, Tennessee: Woman Bilked By Foreclosure Relief Program (FTC Shut Down Company Last Month). Heather Means is a newly divorced mother of two. When she got behind on her mortgage payments, a letter from National Foreclosure Relief sounded perfect. She paid them $1,000 and never heard from them again. Neither did her mortgage company. She isn't the only one who has had trouble with National Foreclosure Relief, Inc. The Federal Trade Commission shut down the California company last month. The FTC said "many consumers who retain NFR's services ultimately lose their homes to foreclosure."

  • Oklahoma City, Oklahoma: Scammers Prey On Troubled Homeowners (Group Shares Name With Legitimate Mortgage Help Network). Lori Marderosian said she gave cash to a mortgage consultant who claimed to be from a government-approved network called Hope Now. "I gave him $1,800," she said. "I waited for phone calls, which never came." After five months, Marderosian said she heard nothing and discovered that the Web site had disappeared. She said that even though the site had called itself Hope Now, it wasn't affiliated with the real company of the same name. There have been plenty of complaints about the company that called itself Hope Now. The New Jersey Attorney General's Office filed a lawsuit charging that it used deceptive conduct and charged up-front fees. The FTC has followed with its own lawsuit and obtained a federal court order to stop the company from doing business.

  • Fort Worth, Texas: Local couple fall victim to alleged scammers. In early March, the 31-year-old man and his 27-year-old wife tapped a Houston company to renegotiate their home loan. They provided all the personal information requested by the firm. But a few weeks later, when they tried contacting the company, its phones had been disconnected and its Web site had been taken down, according to a report the couple filed with police on March 16. Similar to the police report that he and his wife filed, complaints against Excel Loss Mitigation have come in from the Texas cities Grand Prairie, Temple and Pasadena, said Monica Russo, an investigator for the Better Business Bureau in Houston. Russo said eight complaints lodged with her office this month accuse Excel Loss Mitigation of bilking struggling homeowners out of $700 to $1,500 each. Eight complaints are a lot, but the number of actual victims is probably much higher, she said. "For every one complaint, there’s 20 others we never hear about," Russo said.

  • Houston, Texas: Company Claims It Can Stop Foreclosure. Some homeowners facing foreclosure turn to a Houston company called Excel Loss Mitigation for help. But after paying to have their home loans modified customers find the company gone and it's owner denying any involvement. The website for Excel Loss Mitigation is gone, phone numbers are disconnected.

Saturday, March 28, 2009

Sleazy Debt Collection Tactics Featured On Dateline NBC

Dateline NBC ran an investigative report Friday night on the debt epidemic and the sleazy tactics used by some bill collection agencies and "debt scavengers" in hounding consumers into making payments on delinquent credit accounts.

To watch the full broadcast, see Inside The Financial Fiasco: Debt Trap.

Loan Modification Firm Workers Flee Offices As ACORN Demonstrators Prepare To Protest; Accuse Company Of Clipping Homeowners Out Of Upfront Fees

In Los Angeles, California, the Los Angeles Times reports:
  • Consumers trying to warn the public about so-called loan modification scams found themselves tripping an alarm of another sort Wednesday: About 15 of them got stuck in a Buena Park office building's elevator during a demonstration.

  • The failed protest was the latest in a string of tough breaks for a group of about 30 mostly elderly and Latino homeowners who gathered Wednesday outside the offices of a company called Centre Legal. Many of the demonstrators are about to lose their homes to foreclosure. Several had paid Centre Legal or one of its affiliates(1) thousands of dollars to help them work out easier payment terms, but said they received nothing in return.

***

  • [W]hen protesters entered the building, they found Centre Legal's fourth-floor offices empty. Neighboring tenants said the company's workers fled minutes earlier down a set of back stairs, perhaps tipped off by the gathering of homeowners in the parking lot.

For more, see Protest of alleged loan modification scam goes nowhere (An elevator mishap adds to the frustration of homeowners gathered at the offices of Centre Legal, a company they say took their money but did nothing to help them).

(1) According to the story, ACORN alleges that a number of Southern California homeowners have paid fees to Centre Legal but received nothing in return. ACORN said the company has also operated under the names Centro Legal, Modificate and Gigante Mortgage.

Florida High Court Issues Administrative Order Creating Task Force On Residential Mortgage Foreclosure Cases

The Florida Bar News reports:
  • The [Florida] Supreme Court has created a Task Force on Residential Mortgage Foreclosure Cases to recommend policies, procedures, strategies, and methods for easing the backlog of pending foreclosure cases while protecting the rights of parties. Chief Justice Peggy Quince, in a March 9 administrative order, said the residential mortgage foreclosure crisis is of statewide proportions and should, to the extent possible, be addressed on a statewide basis with uniform rules, policies, and procedures to manage cases, protect the rights of homeowners and lenders, and to ease the burden on the courts. The chief justice asked the task force to submit an interim report and recommendations no later than May 8 and a final report no later than August 15.

For more, see Supreme Court creates task force to study foreclosures.

Go here for the Florida Supreme Court's administrative order.

Recovering Damages From Those Engaged In The Unauthorized Practice Of Law

A recent story in The Florida Bar News may be of interest to those in Florida who have suffered monetary damages when doing business with individuals and companies whose activities constitute the unauthorized practice of law (which could include non-attorney loan modification firms engaged in providing forensic loan audits in search of violations of relevant lending and consumer protection laws):
  • Florida residents have legal recourses when they have been damaged by those committing the unlicensed practice of law, according to The Florida Bar. The Bar has provided the above response to a request from the Supreme Court, which is considering an appeal from the Fourth District Court of Appeal in Goldberg v. Merrill Lynch Credit Corporation, 981 So. 2d 550 (Fla. 4th DCA 2008).

  • The appeal is two consolidated class action cases where the plaintiffs sued alleging that corporations engaged in the unlicensed practice of law when they prepared closing documents and other paperwork in connection with mortgages. The Fourth DCA dismissed the case, saying the plaintiffs could not seek civil remedies absent the finding by the Supreme Court of unlicensed practice of law.

For more, see Damaged by UPL? The Bar argues the public has a right to redress.

Go here for The Florida Bar's amicus brief.

Go here for links to all the briefs filed in this case (scroll down to case #SC08-1360 Goldberg, et al. v. Merrill Lynch Credit Corporation, et al.).

Go here for information on Filing an Unlicensed Practice of Law Complaint with The Florida Bar. UnauthPractOfLawTheta

Unpaid Bill Results In Water Shutoff For One South Florida Townhome Community; 60+% Of Homeowners Delinquent On Monthly Maintenance Fees

In Broward County, Florida, the South Florida Sun Sentinel reports:
  • When Peter Lynch went to make coffee in his Blue Lake townhouse Wednesday morning, the tap was dry. "I looked outside and saw the people from the county turning the water off," said Lynch, who is president of the townhome condo association. A Broward County official said after 2 1/2 months of unpaid bills and with $8,100 owed, the shut-off after 24 hours' notice was proper. [...] More than 60 percent of the homeowners are delinquent on [monthly maintenance] fees, Lynch and J.D. Keating of Phoenix Property Management both said.

***

  • Each month, homeowners pay $328 maintenance that includes water use charged on master meters, not to individual units.

For more, see Broward County cuts off water to townhouse community ($8,100 owed to Broward; 60 percent of owners delinquent on fees).

Fire Officials Give Two Dozen Tenants In Unfinished Building The Boot; Developer Nearing Foreclosure Allowed Renters To Move In, Despite No COs

In Pawtucket, Rhode Island, The Providence Journal reports:
  • A scene of desperate economic times played out [Wednesday] inside a former mill, where fire officials evicted as many as 28 people because their new apartments were so unfinished as to be fire hazards. The project manager said she allowed the tenants in — even though their apartments lacked sprinklers or occupancy certificates — because she feared losing them as customers.

***

  • Fire officials made a surprise visit to the complex Tuesday after receiving a tip that people were living in what amounts to an active construction site. Fire Chief Timothy P. McLaughlin said they discovered that the project had no working fire alarm or sprinkler system and limited emergency lighting, and that people had unrestricted access to areas under construction and demolition.

***

  • McLaughlin said First National Development began moving people in last fall to stave off a threat of foreclosure.

For more, see Fire officials evict tenants at unfinished apartment complex.

Rent Scam Victim Plays Key Role In Apprehending Suspect While In The Process Of Ripping Off Another

In Houston, Texas, KVUE-TV Channel 11 reports on a woman who, after being ripped off out of $2,500 by an alleged scam artist who rented her a vacant home he didn't own, turned the tables on him and played a key part in apprehending him while he was in the process of running the same scam on another prospective renter. He reportedly told the prospective tenants that he worked for an investor who was saving homes from foreclosure, and then renting them out.

For the story, see Woman helps police catch alleged scam artist.

Go here, go here, and go here for posts on phony landlord rent scams. PhonyLandlordScamZeta

Friday, March 27, 2009

Court Temporarily Prohibits Central Florida Loan Modification Firm From Charging Upfront Fees

From the Office of the Florida Attorney General:
  • Attorney General Bill McCollum [Thursday] announced that his office has obtained an emergency court order temporarily prohibiting a Central Florida company from charging up-front fees for foreclosure-related rescue services. According to the order issued by the Orange County Circuit Court, Wineberg, Lopez, & Rodriguez Company is barred from charging homeowners any fee in advance for providing foreclosure-related rescue services.

For the entire press release, see Court Grants Emergency Request to Halt Central Florida Foreclosure Rescue Company's Up-Front Fees.

Go here for more on the lawsuit against Wineberg, Lopez, & Rodriguez (press release, lawsuit).

Intentional Torching Of Historic Inn Facing Foreclosure Forces 14 Brides To Can Wedding Reservations

In Asheville, North Carolina, WYFF-TV Channel 4 reports:
  • After an arson fire gutted one of the buildings at an inn complex, 14 brides who had weddings planned at the Asheville inn have canceled their reservations. [...] The mansion was built in 1889 as the private residence of Ambassador and Rep. Richmond Pearson. It was considered one of the area's premier public inns. The ownership of Richmond Hill Inn sent out a statement thanking the Asheville Fire Department for its efforts to try to save the historic Mansion Inn building and the heirlooms inside.

***

  • In the statement, the owners said that Richmond Hill Inn has been having financial difficulty because of the economy, and they filed for Chapter 11 reorganization more than a month ago. They also said that the insurance claims from the fire do not in any way benefit the current owners and that “any claims from the destruction of the property at this time would be paid to the current mortgage holders that forced the foreclosure.”

For more, see 14 Brides Cancel Weddings After Fire (Historic Inn Gutted By Arson Fire).

Ex-Home Health Aide Gets 10 Years For Scamming Elderly Couple; Home Lost To Foreclosure

In Norwalk, Connecticut, Norwalk News reports:
  • A former home health aide who scammed an elderly couple out of hundreds of thousands of dollars, forcing them so far into debt that their home was foreclosed upon, was sentenced in Stamford Superior Court on Thursday to 10 years in prison. Nuria Reyes, 61, was given 10 years in prison, time served after five years. She must also pay $70,000 in restitution to her victims and has to give the victims 50 percent of the restitution up front.

***

  • While working as a home health aide for Lee and Mary Kent from 2003 to 2006, Reyes applied for and obtained mortgages and a home equity line of credit on the victims' home at 14 Saranac St. during her employment.

For more, see Aide who scammed Norwalk couple given 10-year sentence.

Go here, Go here, Go here, Go here, Go here, and Go here for other posts related to deed or refinancing scams by forgery, swindle, power of attorney abuse, etc.

Go here, here, here, here, here, and here for other posts on elder financial abuse. FinancialAbuseOfElderlyAlpha DeedGammaTheft

Foreclosure Scam Alerts Coming Soon To A Theater Near You

The Wall Street Journal reports:
  • The Federal Reserve is coming soon to a theater near you. The subject won't be the drama inside the central bank or its role in the current financial crisis. Rather, Fed officials plan to launch advertisements in movie theaters to warn homeowners about foreclosure scams. Intended to extend the reach of consumer warnings on the Fed's Web site, the ads will run in 14 cities with high-foreclosure housing markets and an outbreak of scam artists charging for guidance that is free from nonprofits working with the government.

For more, see Fed Features: Ads at Movies Warn Against Scams.

Virginia Closing Attorney Gets Two Years In Richmond-Area Equity Stripping Foreclosure Rescue Scam

In Richmond, Virginia, WTVR-TV Channel 6 reports:
  • [A] key player in a local mortgage rescue scheme is going to prison. [...] Prosecutors say Colin Connelly conspired with others from Walkwood Properties to commit mortgage fraud and Connelly admits to preparing fraudulent Housing and Urban Development documents and will now spend two years in prison.

***

  • Prosecutors say Connelly was hired by Darrell Underwood, owner of Walkwood Properties to close on a number of homes under Walkwood's real estate program. The court documents say the housing deals were done without full disclosure to the sellers about how the transactions worked and a huge portion of the equity in the victims' homes was skimmed to Walkwood and other entities.

***

  • Connelly begins his sentence next month. Once released from prison, he must pay back $376,000 to his victims. As for Darryl Underwood, he's been indicted on 41 charges including bank fraud and money laundering. He goes on trial in June.

For the story, see Lawyer Sentenced In Foreclosure Scheme.

For the criminal charges against Connelly, see:

San Diego DA Seeks Help Rounding Up Add'l Victims Of Land Patent Foreclosure Rescue Scam

In San Diego, California, XETV-TV Channel 6 reports:
  • Authorities asked for the public's help Wednesday in locating additional victims of a San Diego foreclosure fraud scam in which victims were falsely told that "land patents" would protect their properties from foreclosure. District Attorney Bonnie Dumanis said 61-year-old Larry Smith and five alleged accomplices sold the bogus "land patents" to homeowners, claiming the victims could pay only 10 percent of their mortgage payment each month and could force lenders to "re-contract" the loan amounts.(1)

***

  • So far, more than 20 victims have come forward saying they lost tens of thousands of dollars in the real estate scam, Dumanis said. Anyone who believes they may be a victim in the case was asked to call (619) 531-4475.

For more, see Victims Sought in Mortgage Foreclosure Scheme.

For some of the documents related to this scam:

Go here for other posts on the land patent allegations against this group.

(1) The defendants -- Smith, Maria Candida Capa, Margarita Gaviola, Jessica Refuerzo, Julita Whittingham and Edgardo Orcino -- are accused of defrauding homeowners out of more than $100,000 in 2007 and 2008.

Mass AG Files Civil Charges Against Loan Modification Firm; Alleges Collection Of Illegal Upfront Fees, Violations Of State Consumer Protection Act

From the Office of the Massachusetts Attorney General:
  • Attorney General Martha Coakley’s Office has obtained a temporary restraining order against Express Modifications, Inc., d/b/a “Loan Mods By Lawyers, Inc.,” which ran prominent advertisements in a local newspaper last month offering to help homeowners avoid foreclosure. In a complaint filed in Suffolk Superior Court [Wednesday], the Attorney General’s Office alleges that the advertisements were unfair and deceptive, in violation of the Massachusetts Consumer Protection Act, because they falsely give the impression that Express Modifications would provide the homeowner with the services of an attorney, and would guarantee a loan modification that would improve the homeowner’s financial situation dramatically and save the home from foreclosure.(1)

For the entire press release, see Attorney General Martha Coakley Obtains Temporary Restraining Order Against Company for Deceptively Advertising Foreclosure Relief Services and Soliciting Illegal Advance Fees.

(1) According to the Massachusetts AG, the advertisements in question ran on three dates in February 2009 in the Boston Metro newspaper. The company offered to assist homeowners to “Save Your Home, Modify Your Loan,” and “Stop Foreclosure; Call NOW!” and directed homeowners to the website LoanModsByLawyers.com. The Attorney General’s investigation of the company and its operations also revealed that the company demands a $1,500 up-front fee before providing services to help homeowners avoid foreclosure. Such advance fees are illegal under regulations issued by the Attorney General’s Office in 2007 to combat various unfair business practices that target homeowners facing foreclosure. The Attorney General’s Office also determined that although the company used the name “Loan Mods By Lawyers,” there appeared to be no licensed attorneys on staff.

Florida Bar Issues Ethics Alert For Lawyers Working With Loan Modification Firms

The Florida Bar has recently issued an "Ethics Alert" in which it provides Florida attorneys some guidance as to what activities they should steer clear from when forging working relationships with non-attorney loan modification firms.
  • [T]his alert does not address every potential problem or concern. Lawyers should not assume that conduct is permissible merely because it is not listed [herein].(1)

For more, see Ethics Alert: Lawyers should be very wary of loan modifiers.

For more from The Florida Bar:

Go here and Go here for other posts on issues relating to attorneys, loan modifications, and the unlicensed/unauthorized practice of law.

(1) The list of prohibited activities contained in the alert:

  • Cannot pay a referral fee or give anything of value to a nonlawyer for referring distressed homeowners to the lawyer. [Rule 4-7.2(c)(14)]
  • Cannot be paid by a nonlawyer to provide services to distressed homeowners. [Rule 4-5.4(a)]
  • Cannot directly or indirectly divide fees with a nonlawyer. [Rule 4-5.5(a)]
  • Cannot assist in the unauthorized practice of law by: (a) providing legal services for a distressed homeowner while employed as in-house counsel for a nonlawyer company; (b) forming a company with a nonlawyer to perform foreclosure related services if any of the services are the practice of law; or (c) assisting a nonlawyer individual or company in providing services that the individual or company is not authorized to provide or are otherwise illegal.[Rule 4-5.5(a)]
  • Cannot assist a nonlawyer in violating the provisions of the Foreclosure Rescue Act, Section 501.1377, Florida Statutes. [Rule 4-8.4(d)]
  • Cannot directly contact distressed homeowners to offer representation (including by telephone or facsimile) and cannot allow someone else to directly contact distressed homeowners on the lawyer’s behalf. [Rules 4-7.4(a) and 4-8.4(a)]
  • Cannot accept referrals from non-lawyers acting in the guise of a “lawyer referral service” (legitimate lawyer referral services must comply with a rule which requires all advertisements and contact with prospective clients to be in compliance with the attorney advertising rules, in addition to other requirements) [Rule 4-7.10]
  • Must have a direct relationship with distressed homeowners who hire the lawyer for representation. [Rules 4-1.1, 4-1.2 and 4-1.4]
  • Cannot allow a nonlawyer to choose a lawyer for a distressed homeowner or direct a lawyer’s representation of a distressed homeowner. [Rules 4-1.1, 4-1.2, 4-1.4, and 4-5.5(a)]

The above cited rules can be found in Chapter 4 of the Rules Regulating The Florida Bar: Rules of Professional Conduct (for pdf version, try here - 139 pages).

According to the Ethics Alert, several ethics opinions, Opinions 92-3 and 95-1 in particular, discuss similar proposals and the ethics problems that arise when lawyers enter business arrangements with nonattorneys. UnauthPractOfLawTheta

Indianapolis-Area Prosecutor Considering Mortgage Fraud Charges In Alleged Rent Skimming Scam

In Indianapolis, Indiana, WISH-TV Channel 8 reports:
  • The Keystone Towers were once an upscale apartment complex, the home of professional athletes and up-and-comers. The towers, which sit on the main highway between Indianapolis and Fishers, have deteriorated to the point of blight. They are infested with rats, human feces and sometimes, the homeless.

***

  • Documents compiled by investigators show the building has been owned by a number of people, most recently Southeastern Partners of Hickory, North Carolina. But investigators believe the problems of Keystone Towers can be traced to one man, Jorges Newberry, who they say bought the towers in 2003 and then abandoned it.

  • Indianapolis Housing Agency Executive Director Bud Myers said, "What Jorges has done is take money off the top, put it in his pocket and moved on to other communities, other cities, other states."

  • Marion County Deputy Prosecutor David Wyser is reviewing charges, including welfare and mortgage fraud against the Newberry. He believes it's all part of a scam. "They buy these properties, they obtain loans, they default on these loans. They take all the money, they leave and they leave it in foreclosure -- then transfer title. They obtain payments through HUD programs even after the property has been sold," explained Wyser.

For more, see Special Report: Indy Eyesore (A once prominent landmark has becomea mess). RentSigmaSkimming

Thursday, March 26, 2009

Florida AG's Assault On Upfront Fee Loan Modification Firms Continues; Accuses Group Of Violating UPL, Foreclosure Rescue Fraud Statutes In Civil Suit

From the Office of the Florida Attorney General:
  • Attorney General Bill McCollum today announced that his office has obtained an injunction against a South Florida loan modification company and its owner to freeze the company’s assets until a lawsuit filed against the company could be heard in court. Miami-based Mortgage Crisis Solutions Association, LLC and owner Donald Gillette are accused of charging homeowners in foreclosure up-front fees as high as $2,995 for loan modification services, but never providing the services. Additionally, the lawsuit alleges Gillette and his company improperly advertised legal services and counsel.

***

  • The lawsuit alleges multiple violations of the Foreclosure Rescue Fraud Prevention Act and the Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act. Full victim restitution has also been requested.(1) A copy of the lawsuit has been served on Gillette and his employee, Flynn McCarthy.

For the entire Florida AG press release, see Attorney General Files Injunction to Freeze Assets of South Florida Loan Modification Company.

For more from the Florida AG's office:

(1) The lawsuit also accuses the group of engaging in the unauthorized practice of law. See lawsuit - paragraph 27. A related company, Property Solutions Specialists, Inc., is also named in the lawsuit and allegedly guaranteed to make available all laws applicable to the homeowners’ situation to better assist them with the defense against foreclosure, even though the company is not a legal services entity. Also named as defendants are One Source Communications, Inc. and Nationwide Financial Partners, Inc.UnauthPractOfLawTheta

Lawyer, NYC Dominatrix Bagged In Alleged $50M Mortgage Scam; Scores Of High End Homes End Up Foreclosed; Fetish Customers "Posed" As Straw Buyers: DA

In Suffolk County, New York, Newsday reports:
  • A former Suffolk legislator, a Manhattan dominatrix and several other people were charged Wednesday in what Suffolk prosecutors said was a $50 million web of mortgage fraud that began in a Manhattan fetish club and ended with scores of pricey Southampton homes ownerless and in foreclosure. George Guldi, 57, of Westhampton Beach, a private attorney since leaving the Suffolk Legislature in 2003, acted as the lawyer in dozens of fraudulent transactions that made him millions, prosecutors said. Guldi and others took out mortgages for more than 50 East End homes on behalf of fake buyers, pocketed the money, then left the houses to languish once payments came due, prosecutors said.

***

  • Prosecutors said the fake borrowers, or straw buyers, were recruited by a Manhattan couple, Donald MacPherson, 65, and Carrie Coakley, 38, from among the clientele of their Manhattan sexual fetish fantasy business, Arena Studios.(1)

For more, see DA: Ex-pol, dominatrix ran mortgage fraud scheme.

See also, Prosecutors: Here's how mortgage scam worked.

For story update, see Attorney to Challenge Office Raid After Arrest in Mortgage Scam Tied to Dominatrix Club.

(1) According to Arena Studio's Web site, the Broome Street company provides space for dominatrixes to meet clients, boasts a "beautifully decorated and fully equipped private dungeon," and, among other items, rents out "medieval torture" implements, bondage furniture and three kinds of whips, Newsday reports. In return for payments of $5,000 to $10,000, clients of the dungeon and others posed on paper as buyers of expensive homes all over the Town of Southampton, Suffolk DA Thomas Spota said.

Mueller: FBI Swamped By Mortgage Fraud Cases

New York Newsday reports:
  • FBI Director Robert Mueller told a congressional panel Wednesday that financial fraud investigations are straining the bureau's resources to fight crime. Mueller said his agency has seen mortgage fraud cases balloon to more than 2,000, in addition to more than 566 open corporate fraud investigations. He also said the bureau has had to shift resources from other criminal work.(1)

For more, see FBI: We're swamped by mortgage fraud cases.

(1) That growing caseload includes "in excess of 100" mortgage fraud investigations being run out of the New York office, which covers Long Island, the five boroughs and six northern counties, a spokesman said. The bulk of the local caseload - ranging from mortgage schemes involving straw buyers to bogus foreclosure rescue scams - is in Brooklyn and Queens.

Seventh Defendant In Maryland-Based Equity Stripping Foreclosure Rescue Scam Cops Plea; Responsible For $16.8M+ In Lender Losses

From the Office of the U.S. Attorney in Maryland:
  • Joy Jackson, age 41, of Fort Washington, Maryland, pleaded guilty today to conspiracy to commit mail and wire fraud in connection with a mortgage fraud scheme that falsely promised to help homeowners facing foreclosure keep their homes and repair their damaged credit, announced United States Attorney for the District of Maryland Rod J. Rosenstein.

  • Joy Jackson presided over a ‘money store’ that was in the business of ripping off homeowners and mortgage lenders by submitting fraudulent paperwork to support over $16 million of loans that were never intended to be repaid,” said U.S. Attorney Rod J. Rosenstein. “Instead of helping financially distressed homeowners keep their homes as promised, she secretly used their home equity to buy luxuries for herself, including furs, jewelry and over $800,000 on her wedding.”

***

  • Jackson is the seventh defendant to plead guilty in the Metropolitan Money Store mortgage fraud scheme. [...] Three defendants remain scheduled for trial on July 7, 2009.

For the entire press release, see President of Metropolitan Money Store Pleads Guilty in over $35 Million Mortgage Fraud Scheme (Jackson Personally Responsible for Over $16.8 Million in Losses to Mortgage Lenders and Used Over $800,000 of Fraudulently Obtained Proceeds to Pay for Her Wedding).

See also, The Washington Post: Woman Pleads Guilty in Mortgage Fraud Scam:

  • [I]nstead of helping people hold onto their homes, as they promised, Jackson and her co-conspirators took titles to properties, drained them of equity and charged exorbitant transaction fees, according to prosecutors. [...] Already, 115 victims have been identified in Maryland, and that number is expected to grow, a prosecutor said. Jackson's sentencing is Nov. 16.

For the indictment in this case, see U.S. v. JoyJackson, et al.